Difference between revisions of "Marspedia:Editorial Minutes 4/16/2018"

From Marspedia
Jump to navigation Jump to search
Line 10: Line 10:


==Minutes==
==Minutes==
***WORK IN PROGRESS, NOT DONE***


The group began with some small talk, then discussed what modifications would be needed for the Category picker on the Visual Editor for Mediawiki.  Frank mentioned that a scrolling menu may not work, and instead have a whole modal/view of all the options.  Shaun said a standard dropdown might work.  So more discussion needed here.
The group began with some small talk, then discussed what modifications would be needed for the Category picker on the Visual Editor for Mediawiki.  Frank mentioned that a scrolling menu may not work, and instead have a whole modal/view of all the options.  Shaun said a standard dropdown might work.  So more discussion needed here.
Line 20: Line 17:
Shaun proposed that Mission Planning or Concepts should be a top-level category instead of having 2-3 major sections on missions.  Frank's statement: "Exploration is Exploration".  The group struggled with these and thought that putting these side-by-side would be helpful to compare & decide.  
Shaun proposed that Mission Planning or Concepts should be a top-level category instead of having 2-3 major sections on missions.  Frank's statement: "Exploration is Exploration".  The group struggled with these and thought that putting these side-by-side would be helpful to compare & decide.  


ultimately agreed that we should avoid duplication whenever possible because all Mediawiki categories are flat and should have unique names.
Frank added "(Planning)" to the end of IV. Human Settlement.  Also to create an Urban Planning category with several related ones underneath.
 
Kerri suggest using Google Docs for commenting on this list.  Frank preferred keeping them in the wiki.
 
Shaun suggested Mining & Manufacturing should be a 2nd-level category.  ISRU was removed.


Outreach vs. Advocacy - the group agreed with Outreach for this instead of Advocacy.


Ultimately agreed that we should avoid duplication whenever possible because all Mediawiki categories are flat and should have unique names.


Eventually we settled on the term of "Spacecraft/Robotic" to denote non-human missions, we decided that a "mission" that is in planning stages but approved should have its own page, and that page should be its permanent mission page throughout its lifecycle.  So we wouldn't need to move a topic from future to present to past if it is an "approved" mission.
Eventually we settled on the term of "Spacecraft/Robotic" to denote non-human missions, we decided that a "mission" that is in planning stages but approved should have its own page, and that page should be its permanent mission page throughout its lifecycle.  So we wouldn't need to move a topic from future to present to past if it is an "approved" mission.

Revision as of 04:52, 18 April 2018

We convened as a teleconference using the Zoom.US service on April 16th, 2018 at 10:30AM PST.

Attendees

Kerri Miller, Shaun Moss, Frank Crossman, Jim LeFevre, James Burk (joined late)

Agenda

  • Review Frank Crossman's Categories research
  • Discuss the plan for Categories


Minutes

The group began with some small talk, then discussed what modifications would be needed for the Category picker on the Visual Editor for Mediawiki. Frank mentioned that a scrolling menu may not work, and instead have a whole modal/view of all the options. Shaun said a standard dropdown might work. So more discussion needed here.

We discussed the benefits of separating out some of the "robotic" exploration vs human exploration categories based on Bruce's feedback. Then we discussed the benefits/drawbacks of organizing by past/present/future missions. Also "robotic" may not be inclusive of orbital spacecraft missions. (Most people connotate robotics as land-based).

Shaun proposed that Mission Planning or Concepts should be a top-level category instead of having 2-3 major sections on missions. Frank's statement: "Exploration is Exploration". The group struggled with these and thought that putting these side-by-side would be helpful to compare & decide.

Frank added "(Planning)" to the end of IV. Human Settlement. Also to create an Urban Planning category with several related ones underneath.

Kerri suggest using Google Docs for commenting on this list. Frank preferred keeping them in the wiki.

Shaun suggested Mining & Manufacturing should be a 2nd-level category. ISRU was removed.

Outreach vs. Advocacy - the group agreed with Outreach for this instead of Advocacy.

Ultimately agreed that we should avoid duplication whenever possible because all Mediawiki categories are flat and should have unique names.

Eventually we settled on the term of "Spacecraft/Robotic" to denote non-human missions, we decided that a "mission" that is in planning stages but approved should have its own page, and that page should be its permanent mission page throughout its lifecycle. So we wouldn't need to move a topic from future to present to past if it is an "approved" mission.

Action Items

  • Frank to continue to refine his Proposed List of Categories based on today's meeting, due by next Monday.
  • Technical Subcommittee to continue to work on "Category Picker" to limit the use of categories on articles to the final list we come up with.